As You can see Cnet is also getting hit hard by the Gerstmann firing. You can tell how much they have dropped after the firing. What do you think they will do? One angry BOL listener said this?
Hey buzzers,
OK, so I was mighty tempted to pull the plug on all my CNET subscriptions in the wake of the Gerstmann-gate hoopla, but have accepted your position that CNET.com and Gamespot.com are two seperate entities, and agree with Molly that not everyone should be tarred with the same big brush. However, I think there are still some issues here that have not been satisfactorily addressed. On Friday’s podcast, you promised to deal with the Gamespot issue on Monday’s show–you did but, I have to be honest, it didn’t feel particularly whole-hearted. As the self-described reporters on Buzz, it seems to me that you missed all sorts of buzz–the intertubes are packed with stories on this, all of which makes for very interesting reading, even if the medium is, in fact, the real message.
But, here’s my real issue with this. I’ll take, at face value, your assertion that the folks at CNET.com aren’t pressured by editors or advertisers with regard to content. But I can’t shake the deep suspicion that the opposite is true at Gamespot.com. I’ll also accept the assertion that those two sites are independent (more or less). The only conclusion to be drawn is that CNET.com and Gamespot.com are being held to different editorial standards. This certainly goes toward the (very skeptical) buzz about ‘gaming journalism’ that has been zooming around the tubes. At the end of the day, this is a huge sticking point for me, and I still think that ‘CNET Networks’ has some ‘splaining to do.
So does this mean they are having people being mad at them or is it that they are just getting the overflow of people from Gamestop? They I know are not the same entity but are both in the same Company? Mind telling me why they haven’t gone into more discussion of this? It’s like Cnet has been told to be quite also? IS that true or are they just holding there breathe to find out the outcome? I suspect it is Management that is doing the keep quite command. What do you think?